When a Boss Overreacts, The Wheels Come Off

Recently, I met with an executive from a global technology company and we were discussing leaders reacting to a situation versus overreacting. He told me the following story.

An employee was sitting in a desk chair that had wheels on the bottom of the legs of the chair. The employee dozed off and fell asleep in the chair with his shoulder resting against his office wall. As he fell into a deeper sleep the chair began to roll away from the wall. I think most people could finish the rest of this sad story. The employee fell out of the chair and suffered a shoulder injury. The employee went on to file a workman’s compensation claim.

The story does not end here, however. The report of this incident goes all the way up to the CEO. Upon hearing of this incident, the CEO ordered that maintenance crews remove the wheels from the bottom of every office chair in the company. This involved thousands of chairs.

Disruption, Confusion, Suspicion

This move was not only disruptive and caused confusion and sent a message that employees could not be trusted to safely work from a chair that had wheels on its legs, but it was a total overreaction to a situation. This was a classic case of punishing the many for the sins of a few.

Things Happen

As an experienced leader knows, sometimes people you lead do the wrong things. It could be a failure to adhere to a standard or policy. It might be a failure in character leading to unethical action. It might be a lack of judgment or making a poor decision. These situations could trigger the gamut of responses.

In order to hold people accountable, leader actions may range from verbal counseling, retraining, assigning to a position of less responsibility in order to gain footing again, a letter in one’s personnel file, or perhaps the termination of employment.

When I coach executives and provide leadership consulting services to companies and organizations the topic of holding people accountable to adhere to standards usually comes up. I coach leaders to focus on the employee who had the infraction rather than on the group that the employee comes from.

Sure, there can be some exceptions. If a leader sees a trend occurring across the organization, then perhaps the organization may have to change a policy or procedure. However, instituting group punishment as a first result rarely turns out well, especially as it pertains to growing trust in an organization.

Beware of the Emotional Hijack

Just as emails should not be sent when one is at the height of emotions, leaders should not make decisions when their emotions take hold of them. Take a breath, think things through, and think about the second and third-order effects of instituting group punishment rather than simply handling employee infractions on a case-by-case basis.

The 20-foot Goal

By MG John Gronski (USA, Ret,) I love to go on trail runs. I find a great deal of enjoyment in going on runs in the mountains of Pennsylvania on hiking trails and single-track paths. A few weeks ago, I was on one such run. I was at around mile four and found myself...

The Entrepreneurial Mindset

By MG John Gronski (USA, Ret.) Do you have an entrepreneurial mindset? A friend of mine who is working on his Ph.D. recently asked if he could conduct an interview with me as a requirement for his program of study. He is involved in a project that focuses on the...

All In or Go Home

By MG John Gronski (USA, Ret.) Jim Sursely was a remarkable man. He passed away on May 30, 2021, after living an inspiring life. He motivated many people but the lesson he told that resonated most with me was that you had to be all in, 100%, if you were going to...

Upward Leadership

By Major General John L. Gronski (US Army, Retired) I have been getting a lot of questions from mid-level leaders about techniques they can use to assist their boss by providing candid feedback. Some people call this “Leading Up”. I like to use the term “Upward...

Muddy Boots (or Paws) Leadership

By MG John Gronski (USA, Ret.) My dog Scottie has muddy boots. To be more accurate, I guess I should say he has muddy paws. I think all leaders can learn from him. Scottie gets around. He does not sit back behind his desk and let the world around him pass him by. He...

The Case For Leading Up

On December 28, 1978, Flight 173 crashed about 8 miles from the Portland Airport. Of the 181 passengers and 8 crew members aboard, 8 passengers, the flight engineer, and a flight attendant were killed, and 21 passengers and 2 crewmembers were injured seriously....

The Sniffspot

We must build resiliency. Resiliency does not just happen on its own. We must prepare for it. To build our resiliency we must work on our fitness. Of course, physical fitness is essential, but being fit mentally, emotionally, and spiritually also builds resiliency....

Becoming A Veteranpreneur

By guest blogger Jesse Clark As a veteran, you no doubt have skills and experience that can translate into a wide range of industries and fields. You’re likely a self-starter who is no stranger to persevering through challenges and thinking of creative solutions. In...

Behaviors speak louder than values

By MG John Gronski, USA Retired Behaviors speak louder than values It is essential for one to identify their core values. Core values should number between about three to seven values. If everything is a core value, then nothing is a core value. It is important to go...

Wellness Practices For The Workplace

By Rosette Jones Adaptability is one of the qualities business owners need to develop to maintain a fulfilled workforce. What better way to practice it than to adapt to the changing needs of your employees? As the importance of employee wellness becomes more...
Share This